By MAUDLYNE IHEJIRIKA
It was a hot summer Friday afternoon and neighbors were hanging out on their porches, gabbing about the weekend’s block party, when gunfire suddenly erupted.
Nobody on the leafy, normally peaceful 4600 block of North Kostner could believe it—perhaps it was firecrackers or someone hammering?
Then police converged on a home.
“We’ve lived here 50 years, and nothing like this has ever happened,” said Chicago Fire Dept. Capt. Tom Malone, who lives directly across the street from the home where the killings took place in the Northwest Side Mayfair neighborhood.
“I came out to clean out the garage when I heard the last ‘pop.’ I stepped out of the garage, listened for a minute, then said, ‘Nah, it couldn’t be.’ People are just in shock. This is a very tight-knit community, the type of place where people live for over 30 years. We were getting ready for our block party tomorrow.”
Police said they were conducting a homicide investigation, and had cordoned off the home with red tape Friday, as neighbors milled around, watching in shock from their porches, the street and the sidewalk.
According to police, about 5:25 p.m., officers performing a well-being check at the home found the three men unresponsive inside. All three were pronounced dead at the scene, the Cook County medical examiner’s office said. Police had to force their way in to the property and recovered a gun from the scene.
Neighbors said the father, his wife and his daughters had lived in the home for a few years. The medical examiner’s office confirmed that the three men lived in that block.
Neighbor Rick Szontagh said he saw one of the sons arrive at the home at 2:30 p.m. An hour later, he saw one of the daughters arrive at the home. A few minutes later, police swarmed the home, he said.
“I’d see the old man out mowing the lawn in the summer, or clearing off his car in the winter, and we’d speak. It’s a shocker,” he said.
Others who knew the family well described them as a friendly, hard-working, close-knit group.
One brother was in advertising, while the other, who was in the construction trade, seemed to be the family’s chief provider, said next-door neighbor Walter Eliasen, adding that the brother had done work for him on his home.
“I knew [the father] and his wife very well. [He] always went to church on Sundays. They were friendly, and we would talk. They were just hard-working people,” said Eliasen.
“We never noticed any problems, no arguments, no problems, nothing at all.”
Eliasen was standing with another neighbor on the sidewalk outside his home, and said they had seen the father and one of the sons out in their backyard talking, when the second son pulled up to the home.
“I asked him if he was coming to the block party and he said yes, and I told him to remind [his father] about the block party. Then he went in,” Eliasen said.
“Minutes later, we heard, ‘Bang, bang, bang, bang, bang.’ We thought that must be a nail gun or something. We kept talking, and then the daughter pulls up an hour later, goes in, and then police come. It’s so sad. They seemed such a nice family.”